Welcome to the delightful world of Benjy's Kosher Pizza, a beloved gem nestled at 12-46 River Rd, Fair Lawn, NJ. This charming pizza joint has garnered a stellar reputation for its unwavering commitment to crafting delicious kosher pizzas that keep customers coming back for more. Whether you're a local or just passing through, Benjy’s is a culinary destination worth making a stop.

As you step inside, you'll find that Benjy, the heart and soul behind the operation, takes immense pride in every pie he prepares. His passion for pizza is evident in the tradition and care put into each slice. According to dedicated patrons, including Guy T Kaufman, "the pizza here is nothing short of amazing," making it an essential stop for food lovers in the area.

Benjy's menu is diverse, offering everything from classic Plain Cheese Pies to unique creations like the French Fry Pie and Garlic Pie. Each pie is fully customizable, inviting you to unleash your creativity by adding your favorite toppings—a perfect playground for pizza enthusiasts. For those seeking hearty options, the Baked Ziti Pie, topped with mozzarella and tomato sauce, is a standout, while the White Pizza, featuring creamy ricotta, caters to those who prefer sauce-free indulgence.

Not to be overlooked, the Calzones are equally enticing. The Plain Calzone filled with ricotta and mozzarella offers a warm embrace, while the Veggie Calzone is loaded with fresh, mouthwatering vegetables that enhance the wholesome experience. Tali Yess, a regular, expresses her devotion to Benjy's, stating she visits at least once a week for a slice of the best kosher pizza in Fair Lawn, exemplifying the restaurant's loyal following.

The dining experience at Benjy’s extends beyond the food. The atmosphere is clean and welcoming, with ample seating for families. David Nissenbaum describes the space as "spacious," perfect for an enjoyable outing after activities like mini-golf. Friendly service adds to the charm, reflected in consistent praises from customers.

In addition to pizza and calzones, the menu also features tantalizing mains like Falafel, Hummus Plate, and savory Eggplant Parm—each crafted to perfection. For those visiting with diverse tastes, the offerings cater to all, ensuring a fulfilling meal for everyone.

In summary, Benjy's Kosher Pizza is more than just a pizza place; it’s a community hub where tradition, flavor, and great service collide. With numerous accolades from passionate customers, including Joshua Berdugo who praises it as "the best pizza I’ve had in the U.S.," this establishment is a must-try for anyone who finds themselves in Fair Lawn. So next time you crave a memorable meal, remember Benjy’s—where every bite tells a story.